Wall Street Journal Talks with “The Ponzi Book” Co-Author Kathy Bazoian Phelps about Madoff-NY Mets Settlement

The Wall Street Journal's Bankruptcy Beat blog yesterday featured a conversation with bankruptcy attorney Kathy Bazoian Phelps of Danning, Gill, Diamond & Kollitz, LLP, co-author of the The Ponzi Book: A Legal Resource for Unraveling Ponzi Schemes and author of the The Ponzi Blog, about the Mets $162 million settlement with the Madoff bankruptcy estate. In the article, Phelps expressed her disappointment that the settlement forestalled a deeper examination of two common defenses used in Ponzi-scheme related litigation. The first defense cited by Mets owners Fred Wilpon and Saul Katz was that they acted in "good faith" when, as alleged, the unrealistic profits they garnered from their investment in Madoff's funds should have raised red flags as to the legitimacy of the investment. A jury finding that Wilpon and Katz acted with "willful blindness" could have resulted in a jury verdict in favor of Madoff trustee Irving Picard for as much as $386 million. The other defense claimed by the Mets owners was the "stockbroker harbor" defense, which creates a safe harbor for transfers constituting settlement payments made by a stockbroker.  In a prior decision in the Picard v. Katz case, Judge Rakoff had upheld the defense as to all transfers other than those made with actual fraudulent intent, which eliminated nearly $1 billion of Picard's claims.  The bankruptcy court in the Madoff case had previously declined to allow this defense in other cases given the fraudulent nature of Madoff's scheme.  Since this is a zero sum defense, Phelps noted that this is a "huge issue for trustees" which will now not be resolved by an appellate court in light of the settlement.        

Read the WSJ Bankruptcy Beat blog article.

See also: Stockbroker Safe Harbor Defense in Ponzi Schemes Remains Unresolved Following Picard v. Katz Settlement

For more information about LexisNexis products and solutions connect with us through our corporate site.