State Net Capitol Journal: States Cooling on Renewable Energy

States' recent passion for renewable energy appears to be running out of steam. Sixteen of the 29 states with renewable portfolio standards are considering legislation that would scale back those mandates, according to the North Carolina Solar Center, a partnership between the U.S. Energy Department and North Carolina State University.

"Activity against renewable portfolio standards has been increasing in the past year," said Justin Barnes, a senior policy analyst at the Solar Center. "There haven't been any outright repeals yet, but we've seen some watering-down."

North Carolina legislators began debating a bill in March that would cut the state's current renewable energy target for utilities'- 12.5 percent by 2015 - in half and then eliminate the requirement altogether in 2021. Colorado's senate passed a bill last month that would actually increase the amount of energy utilities have to obtain from renewable sources but also expand the definition of renewable energy to include sources such as methane produced from coal mining. Connecticut, likewise, is considering including large hydroelectric plants in its definition of renewable energy.

"Connecticut has thrown up the white flag on its ambitious renewable targets, and is now negotiating its terms of surrender," said Nick Culver, an analyst at New Energy Finance in New York. "Instead of simply easing back targets, they intend to widen eligibility criteria to include imported hydropower from Canada that would have been built regardless, which amounts to pretty much the same thing."

The arguments in favor of such proposals tend to be about cost, with the lower price of natural gas brought by the rise of hydraulic fracturing having made more expensive solar and wind power projects less appealing.

"We could never have imagined in 2007 such an abundance of domestic natural gas," said North Carolina General Assembly Majority Whip Mike Hager, who introduced his state's renewable-energy scale-back legislation, which he expects to pass the GOP-controlled Legislature and be signed by Gov. Pat McCrory (R) this year. "We need that Marcellus shale gas to offset the high cost of renewables and prevent electricity prices from rising further. It's like raising children: they need to grow up and learn to live in the real world."

Renewable-energy companies like SolarCity Corp., the San Mateo, California-based rooftop energy developer, see the real world a little differently.

"Whenever you see [an anti-renewable energy] effort, peel the onion and find out who's behind it," who's funding the effort, said SolarCity CEO Lyndon Rive. "It's very annoying that people can get away with the shell efforts and call it the people's voice when it's funded by coal."

Rive likely counts Hager among that group of annoying people. The North Carolina majority whip's top campaign donors include utility company Duke Energy and the Charlotte, North Carolina-based utility owner's Progress Energy (PGN) unit, according to the National Institute on Money in State Politics.

Backers of efforts to repeal clean-energy goals in other states include the American Legislative Exchange Council, which released model legislation aimed at doing so - the Electricity Freedom Act - in October, and the Heartland Institute, prompting Carrie Hitt, vice president of state affairs for the Washington-based Solar Energy Industry Association, to remark: "This is a deliberate campaign by conservative think tanks, the Heartland Institute and Alec to overturn renewable energy policy that threatens the fossil industry."

But Todd Wynn, task force director for energy at Alec, said: "Natural gas is a clean fuel, and regulators and policy makers are seeing how it's much more affordable than renewable energy." And in an April 2 policy statement, the Heartland Institute said North Carolina's renewable energy requirements will have cost state ratepayers as much as $1.8 billion by 2021.

"Repealing the North Carolina renewable portfolio standard would help increase disposable income, attract more business investment, and make energy more affordable for consumers," the statement said. (BLOOMBERG, HEARTLAND INSTITUTE, DSIREUSA.ORG, STATE NET)

The above article is provided by the State Net Capitol Journal. State Net is the nation's leading source of state legislative and regulatory content for all states within the United States. State Net daily monitors every bill in all 50 states, the District of Columbia and the United States Congress - as well as every state agency regulation. Virtually all of the information about individual bills and their progress through legislatures is online within 24 hours of public availability.

If you are a lexis.com subscriber, you can access State Net Bill Tracking, State Net Full Text of Bills and State Net Regulatory Text . If you are interested in learning more about State Net, contact us.

To subscribe to the Capitol Journal and access archived issue go to the State Net Capitol Journal.

For more information about LexisNexis products and solutions, connect with us through our corporate site.