The U.S. Supreme Court recently handed down its decision in the case of Astrue v. Capato. The circumstances of the case are ones most of us will never experience. Nonetheless, the case has lessons for everyone. It underscores the importance of creating a precisely worded estate plan that takes all contingencies into account, and keeping it regularly updated.
When Florida resident Robert Capato was diagnosed with esophogeal cancer, he and his wife Karen were concerned that chemotherapy might leave him sterile. He had his sperm frozen for possible future use. Although Capato went on to father a child with his wife, he died in 2002. Karen then underwent in-vitro fertilization while living in Florida, using her late husband's stored sperm. She moved to New Jersey during the pregnancy, and gave birth to twins 18 months after Robert's death.
The Capatos had signed a notarized document stating that "Any children born to us, who were conceived by the use of our embryos, shall in all respects and for purposes, including but not limited to descent of property, be children of our bodies." However, Robert Capato's will, signed in Florida, did not make mention of any children who might be born subsequent to his death. The only beneficiaries mentioned in his will are his wife Karen; the child they conceived when he was alive; and his children from a prior marriage. And therein is the problem: According to Florida law, children conceived after a parent's death cannot inherit from the parent, unless they are referred to in the parent's Will.
The Supreme Court got involved because Karen attempted to claim Social Security Survivor Benefits for the twins. Social Security turned down the application, stating the father had to have been alive when the children were conceived. A federal judge agreed. The case then went to the Circuit Court of Appeals, which reversed the decision, and found its way to the Supreme Court. The Justices ruled unanimously that the twins are not eligible for survivor benefits because the federal government - i.e, the Social Security Administration - must base its decisions upon each state's own inheritance laws. Even though Karen actually gave birth to the twins in New Jersey, they were conceived in Florida, and thus, Florida intestacy laws apply. Wrote Justice Ginsburg: "The law Congress enacted calls for resolution of Karen Capato's application for child's insurance benefits by reference to state intestacy law."
This is highly unusual case, to be sure. Still, all of us can learn from it. Consult with an experienced Elder Law/Estate Planning attorney when drafting your estate plan.
You can read the Supreme Court decision here.
Attorney Joseph S. Karp is a
Florida Bar Certified and Nationally Certified Elder Law Attorney focusing on
Elder Law, Probate, Estate Planning, Asset Protection, Special Needs Planning
and Estate Litigation. He is AV rated by Martindale Hubbell. Mr. Karp is the
founder of The Karp Law Firm, a South Florida law firm with offices in Palm
Beach Gardens, Boynton Beach and St. Lucie, Florida. Mr. Karp was named a
2011 SuperLawyer by SuperLawyer Magazine and a member of the 2011
Florida Legal Elite by Florida Trend Magazine. He is admitted to
practice law in New York as well as Florida. Visit Mr. Karp's Florida Elder Law and Estate Planning
Sign in with your Lexis.com ID to access LEXIS.com Estates, Gifts & Trusts and Elder Law resources
Discover the features and benefits of LexisNexis® Tax Center
View the LexisNexis
Catalog of Legal and Professional Publications
here for a list of available LexisNexis eBooks.
Click here to learn more about
For more information about LexisNexis products and solutions connect with us through our corporate site.