Adoption of AI Tools Continues to Disrupt Law Firm Billing Practices

In This Article

AI Adoption in Law Firms: Disrupting the Billable Hour Model

Alternative Billing Models on the Rise

How AI Tools Improve Profitability in Law Firms

Experience LexisNexis Protégé

Frequently Asked Questions

Updated October 10, 2025

The traditional hourly billing model has long served as the foundation of law firm revenue generation, but the rapid adoption of AI tools is fundamentally reshaping how firms approach client billing and service delivery. This transformation represents more than a technological upgrade, it’s a paradigm shift that challenges decades-old business models and demands strategic adaptation.

Legal AI Adoption Surge and “The Billable Hour”

            Legal industry data paints a remarkable picture of AI’s meteoric rise in legal practice, including one survey that found AI adoption among legal professionals skyrocketed from 19% to 79% last year, which would suggest that AI tools are being utilized at a faster rate than other recent legal tech innovations.

Indeed, the American Bar Association’s 2025 Tech Survey revealed that 93% of mid-sized law firms now use AI tools, representing a fivefold increase from the previous year. The message is clear: AI has transitioned from experimental technology to essential law firm infrastructure.

The implications for traditional law firm billing practices are profound and immediate. Analysis suggests that up to 74% of hourly billable tasks — including information gathering, document review and data analysis — could be automated through AI implementation.

This rapidly changing landscape presents what Harvard Law School’s Center on the Legal Profession described in a 2025 report as a fundamental threat to the traditional billable hour model, which still comprises roughly 80% of law firm fee arrangements, according to Harvard’s estimates.

The mathematics are stark. When productivity increases dramatically through AI automation, but revenue remains tied to time spent doing the work, profits are at risk of decline. This creates a “productivity paradox” in which the more efficient firms become through AI, the less they earn under traditional hourly models.

Alternative Billing Models Gaining Traction

            Some forward-thinking law firms are recognizing this business model disruption and pivoting toward alternative fee arrangements (AFAs) with urgency. One survey found that 85% of firms with more than 20 lawyers now offer alternative billing structures, rising to nearly 90% among firms exceeding 100 lawyers.

            The proof is in the revenue forecasts. Industry projections suggest that AFA revenue, which represented 20.6% of law firm billings in 2022, is expected to reach 72% in 2025. This dramatic shift reflects clients’ growing demand for cost predictability and value-based pricing models.

            “In short, AI doesn’t just threaten the billable hour — it forces a re-evaluation of how legal services are delivered and monetized,” writes legal technology expert Ben Chiriboga in a 2025 article. “The firms that embrace AI while evolving their pricing and service models will gain a competitive edge, while those resistant to change may struggle to sustain profitability.”

            Here are four key alternative law firm billing models that are gaining traction:

1. Flat Fee Arrangements

A May 2025 report found that law firms are billing 34% more of their cases on a flat fee basis now than they were a decade ago. This model is particularly attractive for transactional work, offering clients cost transparency while allowing firms to leverage AI efficiency gains. In fact, when AI can draft initial contracts or conduct due diligence in minutes — rather than hours — flat fees become increasingly profitable for law firms.

2. Contingency Billing

Contingency fee models are expanding beyond traditional litigation engagements into new practice areas, as AI-powered case analysis and outcome prediction tools provide firms with better risk assessment capabilities. Success rates improve when AI assists with case strategy and document review.

3. Success Fee Structures

These law firm billing arrangements often combine base fees with performance bonuses tied to specific achievements or benchmarks. They are gaining in popularity for complex business transactions, where AI tools can accelerate deal completion and improve outcomes.

4. Capped Fee Models

A billing arrangement that places a ceiling on law firm fees for a prescribed project can provide clients with cost certainty while protecting firms from scope creep. AI’s ability to accurately estimate project complexity makes these models more viable and profitable for firms.

The shift toward alternative billing isn’t merely defensive, it’s also strategically advantageous for law firms. When AI handles routine tasks such as legal research, document drafting and data analysis, attorneys can redirect their focus to higher-value activities requiring critical thinking, client counseling and strategic planning. This reallocation of human capital enables firms to justify premium pricing based on outcomes rather than time invested.

Experience LexisNexis Protégé

LexisNexis Protégé is our personalized legal AI assistant with agentic AI technology that intelligently powers productivity, drives next-level work quality, and enables legal and business professionals to unlock new economic value.

Learn more about Protégé’s capabilities or request a free trial today. To learn more about how LexisNexis leverages the power of AI to help legal professionals achieve better outcomes, or to follow along for the latest in Legal AI educational content, please visit www.lexisnexis.com/ai.