Class claims give rise to
certain unique issues regarding the voting on and acceptance of a chapter 11
plan. In particular, because a class claim is filed by one entity on behalf of
many, the court may be called on to determine whether (or to what extent) the
claim should be treated as a single aggregate claim for purposes of voting and
acceptance as opposed to multiple individual claims.
Bankruptcy Standards for Acceptance of a Chapter 11 Plan
In general, a class of claims accepts a plan if creditors holding at least
two-thirds in amount and more than one-half in number of the allowed claims in
the class vote in favor of the plan. In the case of a plan that seeks to
implement a so-called section 524(g) trust for the payment of asbestos claims,
the plan must be accepted by at least 75 percent of voting asbestos claimants
in the applicable class. Where a class is unimpaired, of course, its vote need
not be solicited, and it is deemed to accept the plan.
Class Claims: Who May Vote?
The limited case law on the voting of class claims suggests that a class
representative may vote on behalf of the class, except to the extent individual
class members have submitted their own ballots. In what was evidently the first
case to address the issue, the court in In re Mortgage & Realty Trust was
faced with the question of who should be entitled to vote on behalf of a class
where certain members of a certified class who had individually filed proofs of
claim in addition to the class claim received solicitation materials from the
debtor and voted individually on the proposed plan of reorganization. Addressing
the issue as one of first impression, the court held that the class
representative could vote on behalf of all class members who did not vote in
their individual capacity, but could not vote on behalf of class members who
had cast votes on their own behalf. In this regard, the court's decision can be
analogized to standard voting procedures that allow law firms or indenture
trustees to cast "master ballots" in certain circumstances, subject
to the voting rights of the individual creditors they purport to represent.
Access the full version of "Class Action Claims and
Chapter 11 Plan Confirmation Issues" with your lexis.com ID. Additional
fees may be incurred.
If you do not have a lexis.com ID, you can purchase this commentary and additional Emerging Issues Commentaries from the LexisNexis Store.
Lexis.com subscribers can access the complete
set of Emerging Issues Analyses for Bankruptcy Law and the Bankruptcy Area of Law page.
For more information about LexisNexis
products and solutions connect with us through our corporate site.