Estate and Elder Law

Long Term Care Insurance May Become a Thing of the Past

It seems that the insurance companies really boggled it when it came to pricing out long term care insurance policies.  Long term care policies have been hit by a triple whammy - historically low interest rates, policy holders living longer, and policy holders not dropping coverage at the rates the insurance companies expected.

Some of the huge insurance carriers have washed their hands of the whole situation and have left the market.  Prudential Financial, Inc. announced earlier this month it would stop selling long term care policies to the individual market.  MetLife ended sales of  long term care polices in 2010.  Unum announced In March 2012 that it would discontinue sales to employees of corporations.  Over the past 5 years, 10 of the 20 largest writers of long term care have exited the market.

John Hancock, one of the top 5 largest writers of individual long term care policies isn't exiting the business, but is actively trimming its book of business as it is asking each state to allow it to hike the premiums for existing customers by an average of 40%. reports that in one case an Illinois couple received a premium increase showing a 90% hike, from $3893.40 a year to $7385.52 per year (see The Chicago Sun-Times).  

I find this a bit outrageous.  The policy-holders have paid into their policies all these years and held up their end of the bargain - I pay you money today, and you pay me money tomorrow if I get sick and meet all of your other requirements.  It looks as if the insurance companies are fearful that, oh no, the policy holders might actually (gasp) try to collect on the insurance polices for which they have been dutifully paying their premium all these years.  So, to prevent that from happening, we will tell people that are living on a fixed income (which also hasn't seen any increases due to the low interest rate and inflation environment) that they will either pay up to 90% more, or we will cut them off and all that money that they spent will be for naught.

Now I am not saying the insurance companies can't do this, of course they can, it's in the contract.  What I am saying is that it is the insurance companies, the experts in defining the risk the themselves, who made the "bad deal", and they are the only ones who profit, because they got all those premiums and never had to pay out on all the people who will be forced to cancel their coverage.

As a taxpayer, I find this particularly disturbing, because there are 3 ways to pay for long term care - you money, long term care insurance, and Medicaid.  In this situation the people who tried to plan for their own care by getting long term care insurance, which is precisely what we as a society would like people to do - plan for their own needs - are going to end up dropping coverage and perhaps ending up needed Medicaid to pay for their care.

As an attorney, I counsel people to consider long term care as a responsible investment in their future.  I don't sell it, I don't get compensated in any way when somebody else sells it, but I have seen families have oodles of more options when dealing with long term care issues when those very high costs can be offset by new dollars coming in.  I just can't help but feeling that the stupendous increase in premiums is like the trick where you try to pull the tablecloth off the table, but everything comes crashing down.

Deirdre R. Wheatley-Liss is a shareholder of the Law Firm of Fein, Such, Kahn & Shepard, P.C., with offices in Parsippany and Toms River, New Jersey. She concentrates her practice in the areas of Elder Law, Estate Planning and Administration, Business Planning and Tax Law. Deirdre's individual clients range from their 20's to their 80's and beyond, while her business clients range from start-ups with exciting new ideas to 100+ year old business ventures. Clients seek Deirdre's advice and assistance with a variety of planning issues relating to identifying and meeting their personal, family and business goals, whether in a planning or crises situation.

. . . .

Explore the Estates, Gifts & Trusts and Elder Law resources

Discover the features and benefits of LexisNexis® Tax Center

For more information about LexisNexis products and solutions connect with us through our corporate site.

  • Anonymous
    I think there's nothing wrong with buying long term care insurance. But, it's really not for everyone. Weighing the risks of buying LTCi policies and self-insuring, I could say the latter is more dangerous because it could eat up all your savings and assets. Meanwhile, LTCi can help you save and it can be used together with your retirement savings
  • Anonymous
    In my opinion, long term care insurance will bounce back and regain its spot in the business. It will never go away for the fact that it is a necessity and not just an ordinary commodity. I am fully aware that there are ltc companies that stopped selling this coverage because of high premiums and few people who show interest in purchasing. It is really expensive in nature but if you're one of those people who might need this in the future, you'll be grateful that you've purchased this policy. I do agree that it's not for everyone, so it's it's appropriate to have your health and needs assessed first before purchasing. In this way, you can fully take advantage of the benefits once the time comes that you will need extended care. It's a risk to age without coverage especially when you have family history, high risk factors and you will most likely need long term care in the future. It's best to talk to a specialist in order to be sure that long term care insurance is suitable for you or not.