SNQ Review Options Vary Significantly Between Ex Parte & Inter Partes Patent Reexamination
As discussed back in March relative to inter partes reexamination, the
proper mechanism for seeking review of a denied Substantial New
Question Of Patentability (SNQ) may depend on the status of the claims
of the proceeding. For example, where inter partes reexamination is denied as to certain claims of a request, the appeal of such SNQ denial is improper.
Yet, if all claims are actively reexamined, denied SNQs may be appealed
to the BPAI. Patent Owners may petition the finding of an SNQ in very
limited circumstances. (i.e., an ultra vires Order)
In ex parte patent reexamination, Patent Owners are now expected to appeal the finding of an SNQ based upon the June 25, 2010 Federal Regsiter Notice. Denied SNQs are only petitionable by third parties if reexamination is denied as to all requested claims.
Keeping the various options straight in
your head can be a challenge. Below is a graphic that lays out the
options for easy reference.
View more from Patents Post-Grant
For more information about LexisNexis products and
solutions connect with us through our corporate