In April 2011, a jury awarded Shana Maron $86,000, after finding
that she was paid less than her former male colleagues in Virginia Tech's
Office of University Development. In June, U.S. District Court Judge James Turk
threw out the verdict and ordered a new trial, reports Roanoke.com.
The plaintiff was not happy about the judge's decision.
So she did exactly what we would expect--she posted about it on Facebook,
writing, "What's the law really worth when you can make it up as you
go?" and "Turk is a Turkey." She later added, "The jury
spoke, Tech lost, Turk is a biased bully, and I will still prevail."
Sure enough, one of Maron's Facebook friends reported the
posts to Virginia Tech's lawyers. And, sure enough, they sought a court order
seeking to compel Maron to turn over all of her Facebook postings about the
Why would they want to know what the plaintiff had to say
during the first trial? Maybe because they thought there could be evidence that
could serve as the basis for a mistrial. Or, more likely, maybe the hope to
find comments she made that could be used to impeach her during the second
The judge, though, didn't buy it. He denied Virginia
Tech's motion on October 20, 2011, ruling that the Facebook posts (assuming
they do exist), were not material to Maron's Equal Pay Act claim.
So, what do we learn from this case? First, for
individuals who are parties to a suit (and their counsel), silence is golden.
And silence includes Facebook silence. I've had several interesting discussions
with other attorneys about whether lawyers should monitor their clients' online
activities during litigation. And several plaintiffs' lawyers I know have
amended their retention agreements to reflect a promise by their clients that
they will refrain from posting anything about the case in any online forum,
including Facebook. Second, employers' lawyers should consider whether they
should monitor plaintiffs' online activities throughout litigation.
Read more Labor and Employment Law insights
from Margaret (Molly) DiBianca in the Delaware
Employment Law Blog. Ms. DiBianca is an attorney with
Young, Conaway, Stargatt & Taylor, LLP.
For more information about LexisNexis
products and solutions connect with us through our corporate site.