My Employer Said it Would Not Contest My
Pennsylvania Unemployment Claim; What Does That Mean?
I receive many phone calls from employees who accepted a
voluntary lay-off ("reduction in force" or "RIF") with a promise from their
employer that it "would not contest unemployment," only to later be denied
unemployment benefits by the Pennsylvania Unemployment Service Center. Let me
explain how this works.
When you apply for unemployment benefits, the Unemployment
Service Center will immediately write to your employer to confirm your
wages and the reason that you are no longer employed. Correctly believing
that it is required to provide such truthful information to the Service Center,
the company truthfully states that you voluntarily accepted a RIF. In the
employer's mind, and in fact, merely telling the Service Center these facts
does not constitute "contesting your claim."
If I Accept a Voluntary Layoff, Can I Get Unemployment Benefits in
Depending upon the circumstances, the acceptance of a voluntary RIF is deemed a
voluntary quit. The key here is whether you were in line for immediate
termination if you did not accept the voluntary RIF. Unless you were
slated for immediate termination (absent accepting the voluntary RIF),
accepting the voluntary RIF will be deemed to be a quit "without
necessitous and compelling reason," and you will be ineligible for
However, if you were given the choice between immediate
termination and voluntary RIF, and selected the RIF, you will be eligible for
unemployment, provided that your termination was indeed imminent. If this
option is presented to you, you should call an employment lawyer at once prior
to accepting or rejecting the offer. The key here is that your termination must
be imminent not, for example, something that will very likely occur a week,
month or year down the road.
What is Better, Severance or Unemployment Benefits?
Of course, the main dilemma one faces is weighing the benefits of the severance
and benefits offered in connection with the RIF against the value of the
unemployment benefits you receive if you are terminated as part of a RIF (if
you are RIFed, you will be entitled to unemployment benefits - assume your
benefits will be the equivalent of roughly 10% of your earnings, with the
maximum being $575 per week for at least 26 weeks).
Read more articles
about employment law issues at Philadelphia Area Employment Lawyer, a blog
by John A. Gallagher.
For more information about LexisNexis
products and solutions connect with us through our corporate site.