In this Analysis, Mark S.
Ericsson discusses the tax consequences of a divestiture of property through a
short sale (in which the lender agrees to take less than the loan balance),
foreclosure, or deed in lieu of foreclosure. He writes:
The focus of any inquiry as
to the tax consequences is how much gain and how much cancellation of
indebtedness is recognized in the transaction. Gain is the amount one realizes
over the amount that on has invested, or how much the value increased. Income
is realized to the extent that one's net worth increases, unless the income can
be excluded by statute or case law. In the case of cancellation of indebtedness
income, if the bank agrees to compromise a $20,000 debt to $10,000, one's net
worth has gone up by $10,000 and that is income. As one studies the four
schedules, he or she will note that two factors come into play. First, gain is
taxed federally at a maximum rate of 15% (20% next year) while cancellation of
indebtedness income is taxed at a maximum rate of 35% (39.6% next year).
Therefore, any comparison must start with how much tax is generated at the two
Secondly, both gain and
ordinary income can be excluded. There is one exclusion for gain on principal
residences, and there are five exclusions for cancellation of indebtedness
income. Therefore, one must determine if one of the exclusions applies and if
there is any detriment caused by applying the exclusion.
The exclusion for gain is
the $250,000/$500,000 IRC
Sec. 121 exclusion for homeowners who have owned and occupied the home for two
out of the last five year prior to sale. There are five ways to exclude income
from cancellation of indebtedness income, which are found in IRC
Sec. 108. They are the insolvency exclusion (taxpayer may exclude an amount of
COD Income equal to the excess of the COD Income over the net worth of the
taxpayer immediately after the sale); the bankruptcy exclusion (where personal
liability has been eliminated by a bankruptcy before or within the bankruptcy);
the election to exclude acquisition indebtedness under IRC Sec. 108(a)(1)(E);
and two that rarely apply to personal residences or rentals (farms and property
used in a trade or business).
Access the full version of Taxation of Short Sales and
Foreclosures with your lexis.com ID. Additional fees may be incurred. (approx.
If you do not have a lexis.com ID, you can purchase the
Emerging Issues Analysis content through our lexisONE Research Packages