An investment adviser and its founder, who persuaded a management investment company to create a fund based on a specified investment strategy, were charged with fraud in a proceeding initiated by the SEC. The proposed investment strategy for the fund was presented to the board of directors by Respondents and described in filings made with the Commission. The adviser, however, lacked the ability to implement that strategy. In the Matter of Chariot Advisors, LLC, Adm. Proc. File No. 3-15433 (Aug. 21, 2013).
Respondent Chariot Advisors has been a registered investment adviser since September 2008 when it was founded by sole owner and Respondent, Elliott Shifman. Shortly after founding Chariot Advisors, Mr. Shifman began developing the Chariot Fund. It had an investment objective of achieving absolute positive returns in all market cycles by investing about 80% of the assets under management in short-term fixed income securities while using about 20% of the assets to engage in algorithmic currency trading. That strategy was based on Mr. Shifman’s theory that there were short term inefficiencies in the currency markets which could be exploited.
In late November 2008 Mr. Shifman approached Northern Lights, a registered open-ended series management investment company, with a proposal to create a series based on the Chariot Fund investment strategy. Mr. Shifman provided the Northern Lights with materials which detailed the strategy. He followed-up by making a presentation to the board of directors which largely reiterated the representations in the materials. Based on those representations, the board approved the Chariot Fund as a series of Northern Lights. The investment strategy was to be the fixed income/algorithmic currency trading approach crafted by Mr. Shifman for the fund.
Subsequently, Mr. Shifman entered into talks to sell the fund. Pending a possible change in control the board of Northern Lights requested a second submission. Respondents submitted papers which largely reiterated the fixed income/algorithmic currency trading approach but requested an increased management fee. The papers submitted contained a proposed prospectus which described the proposed investment strategy.
Again the board approved the proposal. A registration statement on Form N-1A was filed with the Commission in June 2009 which described the fixed income/algorithmic currency trading strategy. The registration statement became effective at the end of the month. The fund launched in July 2009.
Control of the fund changed at the end of June 2009 when the registration statement became effective. For the first two months of operation a trader retained by Mr. Shifman directed trading. That person did not use an algorithm. Rather, as Mr. Shifman knew when hiring the trader, she utilized a technical analysis, rules-based approached along with certain market indicators and intuition. Indeed, the fund never had the ability to implement the fixed income/algorithmic approach approved by the board and described in the prospectus and registration statement, according to the Order.
The Order alleges that Chariot Advisors willfully violated Section 15(c) of the Investment Company Act. That Section imposes a duty on an investment adviser to a registered investment company to furnish the information to the board which may be reasonably necessary to approve the contract for the adviser. Respondents also willfully aided and abetted and caused the Chariot Fund’s violations of Investment Company Act Section 34(b). That Section precludes making an untrue statement of a material fact in any registration statement or other document filed or transmitted pursuant to the Investment Company Act. In addition, Chariot Advisers willfully violates Advisers Act Sections 206(1), (2) and (4) while Mr. Shifman willfully aided and abetted and caused Chariot Advisor’s violations of Sections 206(1) and (2), according to the Order. The proceeding will be set for hearing.
For more commentary on developing securities issues, visit SEC Actions, a blog by Thomas Gorman.
For more information about LexisNexis products and solutions connect with us through our corporate site.