Register to receive a printed copy(For Lexis Practice Advisor® Subscribers Only)
Lexis Practice Advisor®Free Trial
Learn More AboutLexis Practice Advisor®
By: Spencer Compton, First American Title Insurance Company
LEXIS PRACTICE ADVISOR RESEARCH PATH: Real Estate > Commercial Purchase and Sales > 1031 Exchanges > Practice Notes
Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code provides that no gain or loss will be recognized when property held for productive use in trade or business or for investment is exchanged for like-kind property that will also be held for productive use in trade or business or for investment. Most states (Pennsylvania being a notable exception) allow such an Exchangor (as defined below) to defer state capital gains tax as well. Put simply, in a 1031 exchange transaction, the seller of qualified property can use the entire equity in the property to purchase Replacement Property (as defined below). Federal and state capital gains taxes are deferred.
MANY REAL ESTATE ADVISORS REGARD THE 1031 EXCHANGE mechanism as one of the few “free lunches” available to ordinary real estate investors. Real estate practitioners should be familiar with 1031 exchange transactions to effectively represent sellers of properties held for business use or for investment. Too many potential 1031 exchange transactions go unrealized, with capital gains taxes paid, due to real estate investors’ lack of information or misapprehensions about the wealth-building benefits of exchange transactions. Real estate and tax advisors owe it to their clients to advise them fully of the advantages of a 1031 exchange. When advising a client regarding the viability of a 1031 tax-free exchange, real estate attorneys should always work in concert with the client’s tax advisor.
Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code and the deferred exchange regulations allow a seller of real estate to defer the federal gain on the sale of real property held for business use or for an investment if
An Exchangor can defer taxes by selling a Relinquished Property (as defined below) and acquiring Replacement Property at a later date, and provided that all of the rules are followed, the transaction will be considered an exchange rather than a sale followed by a purchase. For this to happen, the Exchangor cannot have actual or constructive receipt of the Exchange Funds (as defined below). In this regard, the Exchangor need not actually take possession of the Exchange Funds after the Relinquished Property closes to create a problem. If any of the Exchangor’s agents (such as his or her attorney) takes possession of the Exchange Funds, or if the Exchangor has the right to direct the disposition of the Exchange Funds, the Exchangor can be considered to have constructive receipt of the funds, and the exchange could be compromised.
An Exchangor must have an identifiable interest in both the Relinquished Property and the Replacement Property to have a successful exchange. Acquisition of a 100% interest in an entity whose sole asset is the Relinquished (or Replacement) Property will qualify, but lesser percentages of membership interests, partnership interests, or shares of stock in entities that own the real property will not. In a standard deferred exchange, the deed for the Relinquished Property will be from the Exchangor to the buyer, and the deed for the Replacement Property will be from the seller to the Exchangor. During a standard deferred exchange, the QI (as defined below) will never be in title to either property.
To fully defer all taxes, an Exchangor must accomplish two things:
It should be noted that where an Exchangor invests some, but not all, of the Exchange Funds into the Replacement Properties, capital gains tax will be owed on the balance not invested (boot).
A 1031 exchange begins on the earlier of
and ends on the earlier of
What is the rationale for the 1031 exchange? Where a seller of investment property reinvests its Net Proceeds and retired debt into a like-kind Replacement Property, the seller’s economic position has not changed. It has not received an economic gain or cash with which to pay capital gains taxes triggered by the sale. Accordingly, to require the taxpayer to pay such taxes would be unfair. The tax obligation is not eliminated; rather, it is deferred until the Replacement Property is sold. If the Replacement Property is sold and another 1031 exchange is not initiated, the original deferred gain, plus any additional gain realized since the Replacement Property purchase, is taxed.
The 1031 exchange became law with the Revenue Act of 1921 and remained largely unchanged from 1928 to 1984, when time limits were imposed as a result of the Starker decision. Starker v. United States, 602 F.2d 1341 (9th Cir. 1979). Prior to 1979, 1031 exchanges were accommodated in one daylong closing where the Relinquished Property was closed, followed by the Replacement Property closing. The impact of the Starker decision was that 1031 exchanges did not have to close the same day; the closings could be delayed. What is now known as a forward or standard deferred exchange allows for the Relinquished Property to be closed on one day, followed on another day by the Replacement Property closing. A deferred exchange allows the taxpayer to relinquish current property and receive like-kind Replacement Property in the future. But in 1984, Congress decided to limit the scope of the Starker decision by enacting section 1031(a)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code, a provision that permits deferred exchanges to occur within a specific time frame. In 1984, the 45 and 180 calendar day limits were imposed requiring the potential Replacement Property to be identified by the 45th calendar day post-closing, with the 1031 exchange completed no later the 180th calendar day post-closing.
Susan bought an investment property for $300,000 several years ago and put an additional $100,000 into capital improvements. Her basis is now $400,000. Susan enters into a contract of sale for $600,000. Her capital gain would be $200,000, which, assuming a capital gains tax rate of 23.8%, would mean a $47,600 tax bill. To defer paying this tax, Susan engages a Qualified Intermediary to assist in structuring her sale as the first leg of a 1031 exchange. If Susan wants to defer all gains from the sale of the Relinquished Property, at closing, all of Susan’s Net Proceeds are paid by the buyer or closing agent directly to the QI. The funds are deposited into a segregated interest-bearing escrow account controlled solely by the QI. Within 45 days after the date of closing of the sale of the Relinquished Property, Susan identifies in a writing sent to the QI up to three potential Replacement Properties. If Susan wants to identify more than three properties a rule (the 200% Rule) applies for the identification. In such event, the total value of all identified properties cannot exceed 200% of the value of the Relinquished Property (see Identification Rules, below). Within 180 days of the sale of the Relinquished Property, Susan directs the QI to fund her purchase of one of the Replacement Properties. If there are any remaining funds held by the QI, they are paid over to Susan together with interest earned. Such non-reinvested funds (which are boot) are subject to capital gains tax.
In the event that a property will or may be the subject of a 1031 exchange, it is advisable to include the following language, as specified, in both the contract to sell (Phase 1) and the contract to purchase (Phase 2).
The Exchangor has 45 days from the closing of the Relinquished Property to identify Replacement Property. Proper identification of Replacement Property is a requirement for a valid exchange, and the Exchangor can only acquire property that has been properly identified during the 45-day identification period. Replacement Property that is acquired (i.e., closes) within the 45-day time period is considered properly identified. For property not purchased within the 45-day time frame, the identification must unambiguously describe the property (with an address or legal description), and must be made in writing, signed by the Exchangor and sent before midnight of the 45th day. If multiple Relinquished Properties are grouped together in one exchange, the 45-day time period starts to run as of the closing of the first property.
For any size exchange, a Qualified Intermediary will ideally be a subsidiary of a high net worth, long-standing financial institution, such as a bank or title insurance company. Although there are many smaller companies, and even individuals, who act as Qualified Intermediaries, the Exchangor will be best protected by a deep-pocketed entity willing and able to provide indemnity against any employee malfeasance. The greater the volume of exchanges the QI processes, the lower the fees it is able to charge. Certain persons may not act as the QI. Generally, these include certain relatives of the Exchangor, or someone who, within a two-year period prior to the exchange, has acted as the Exchangor’s agent, such as her attorney, accountant, or real estate broker.
If an Exchangor wants to identify more than one Replacement Property, there are several options. The following are the three most common methods to identify multiple properties:
The Replacement Property must be considered like-kind to the Relinquished Property. The like-kind requirement is broad for real property exchanges. For example, an office building can be exchanged for vacant land, an apartment building can be exchanged for a single family rental home, or a duplex can be exchanged for a retail strip center. Generally, like-kind in terms of real estate means any property held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment that is classified real estate in any of the 50 U.S. states, and in some cases, the U.S. Virgin Islands. A real property within the United States and a real property outside the United States would not be like-kind properties. Multiple properties qualify. For example, a single property may be exchanged for several properties and vice versa.
The QI will provide the documents necessary to consummate the 1031 exchange transaction. Except on occasion in the case of a very large and/or complex transaction, the QI’s forms are not negotiated. The main provisions of the two principal documents in a 1031 exchange transaction are summarized below:
Note that the QI will not warrant the tax consequences of the transaction and will require a representation from the Exchangor that it has consulted and solely relied upon the advice of its own independent legal counsel as well as its tax advisor.
The Exchangor releases the QI from all liability in connection with its participation in the replacement property agreement except liability arising from the QI’s own willful misconduct or gross negligence. The Exchangor acknowledges that the QI has made no representations or warranties concerning the Replacement Property, the physical condition of the Replacement Property, or the condition of legal title thereto. The Seller of the Replacement Property is asked to execute an Acknowledgement that it has been notified of the Assignment Agreement and received a copy thereof.
Extensions for an exchange are not granted on a case by case basis. Where the President declares one or more counties to be federal disaster areas, affected taxpayers who reside, have a business in, or are involved in a 1031 exchange with respect to properties in these counties may be eligible for up to a 120-day time extension for completion of their exchange under the 180-day rule and submission of their 45-day letter identifying prospective Replacement Properties.
Where a 1031 exchange transaction fails for either (i) failure to identify Replacement Property within 45 days or (ii) failure to close within 180 days, the Qualified Intermediary will return the Exchange Proceeds to the Exchangor together with any interest earned, less the Qualified Intermediary’s fee. Note that where the transaction fails after the 45-day identification period has passed, under Section 1031, the Qualified Intermediary may not be able to return the Exchange Proceeds until day 181. The Exchangor will owe capital gains taxes and penalties for late payment if applicable from the date that the Exchangor is entitled to receive proceeds under the Exchange Agreement.
With Revenue Procedure 2008-16, which applies to vacation homes and second residences, the IRS created a safe harbor for taxpayers wishing to use section 1031 for properties that follow a simple set of rules, as set forth below.
For at least two years prior to and after the exchange, and in each of the two 12-month periods in the qualifying period
A reverse exchange occurs when an Exchangor wants to acquire Replacement Property prior to the closing of the sale of the Relinquished Property. Although common terminology calls this type of transaction a “reverse exchange,” the Exchangor does not actually acquire the Replacement Property first and dispose of the Relinquished Property later. Instead, the Exchangor must arrange for an Exchange Accommodation Titleholder (EAT), a special purpose entity (formed by the QI) that is a separate single member limited liability company used exclusively for the contemplated reverse 1031 exchange transaction, to take title to either the Relinquished Property (exchange first transaction) or the Replacement Property (exchange last transaction). A reverse exchange must be set up and structured with an EAT prior to the Replacement Property closing.
Perhaps your client has unexpectedly found an investment opportunity that she must act on before she even has time to consider selling or listing her Relinquished Property. Or, she fears the sale of her Relinquished Property may collapse, and she does not want to lose her Replacement Property acquisition that is closing soon. The reverse 1031 exchange allows her to acquire the Replacement Property first and then subsequently list and sell the Relinquished Property within the prescribed 1031 exchange deadlines. The actual 1031 exchange portion of the reverse 1031 exchange transaction will be a simultaneous 1031 exchange either at the beginning or end of her reverse 1031 exchange transaction (depending on whether it is an exchange first or an exchange last structure). In either instance, the EAT will acquire and hold or “park” legal title to either her Relinquished Property or her Replacement Property during the reverse exchange transaction.
There are two different types of reverse 1031 exchanges: the exchange last transaction and the exchange first transaction. The steps for each type of transaction are outlined below.
Reverse exchanges under the IRS safe harbor rules must be completed within 180 days of the date the EAT acquires title to the Relinquished Property. In an exchange last transaction, the Exchangor has 45 days from the first closing to identify the Relinquished Property. The 180-day timeframe begins on the day the EAT takes title to the Replacement Property. Most rules that apply to tax-deferred exchanges also apply to reverse exchanges. Each of these transactions must be set up as an exchange, rather than as a sale followed by a purchase. To qualify for a safe harbor reverse exchange, the Exchangor must comply with Revenue Procedure 2000-37, which provides how to properly structure a Reverse 1031 Exchange transaction by using a parking arrangement in conjunction with a simultaneous 1031 Exchange.
Because a reverse 1031 exchange is more complex than a forward 1031 exchange, the QI will provide a greater number of documents:
If the Exchangor cannot find a buyer for the Relinquished Property during the 180-day period, the EAT will transfer the property it is holding to the Exchangor. If this happens, the Exchangor has lost an opportunity to trade in the Replacement Property and has paid some non-fundable fees for the reverse exchange. As an exit strategy, the Exchangor can eventually do a forward exchange with the Relinquished Property once it is ready to close if the Exchangor plans to buy more Replacement Property.
An improvement exchange occurs when the Exchangor wants to acquire Replacement Property and build improvements on it during the exchange period. This usually occurs when the Exchangor determines that he will have exchange funds in excess of the cost of the Replacement Property. The excess equity is used to construct improvements on the Replacement Property. In an improvement exchange, the EAT holds title to the Replacement Property, but the construction may be managed by the Exchangor. The Exchangor must identify what will be constructed on the Replacement Property within 45 days after the Relinquished Property is transferred to the buyer. The exchange must be completed within 180 days, but the construction does not need to be completed during that time. Nevertheless, the only property that is considered “like-kind” for exchange purposes will be property that is considered to be real property (i.e., attached to the land or building).
In a deferred build-to-suit exchange, the Relinquished Property is disposed of and the sale proceeds go to the QI. The Exchangor must identify Replacement Property within 45 days, including a description of what will be built on the property. The EAT acquires the property using the exchange funds. The Exchangor oversees the construction of the improvements and periodically sends invoices to the EAT, who pays them using exchange funds. The Replacement Property is transferred from the EAT to the Exchangor upon the first to occur of (1) construction completion, (2) the expiration of the 180-day exchange period, or (3) when enough value is added to the Replacement Property for full tax deferral.
In a reverse build-to-suit exchange, the Replacement Property is acquired by the EAT first, using funds from the Exchangor or a lender. As with a deferred exchange, the Exchangor supervises the construction and sends invoices to the EAT, but the EAT must borrow money from the lender or the Exchangor to pay the invoices. At some point during the 180-day period, the Relinquished Property is sold and funds are transferred to the QI. If there is more construction needed, the exchange funds can be used for the construction until the 180-day period expires. As with the deferred build-to-suit, the Replacement Property is transferred from the EAT to the Exchangor on the first to occur of (1) construction completion, (2) the expiration of 180 days, or (3) when enough value is added to the Replacement Property for full tax deferral.
Although this practice note has discussed only real property like-kind exchanges, the I.R.C. also contemplates certain defined personal property exchanges such as rental car portfolios, aircraft, livestock, and art works. Where the likekind rules for real property exchanges are broad, the like-kind rules for personal property exchanges are narrow. For example, a cow may not be exchanged for a bull (only for another cow), a bronze sculpture may not be exchanged for an oil painting (only for another bronze sculpture), and so forth. Practitioners are encouraged to consult the relevant sections of the I.R.C. for further illumination.
The number of 1031 exchange transactions has grown steadily since the 2013 increase in the capital gains tax rate. To offer effective representation, attorneys should be familiar with the mechanics of this cost-saving, real property investmentfriendly feature of the I.R.C. Strategic use of the forward exchange, the reverse exchange, or the construction exchange can defer a client’s capital gains tax obligations arising out of a sale of investment property. Advising a client about the possibility of capital gains tax deferral should be on every attorney’s client intake checklist.
S. H. Spencer Compton is vice president and special counsel in the New York City office of First American Title Insurance Company. The author would like to acknowledge the generous assistance of his colleagues at First American Exchange Company: Mark Bullock and Ray Novinc.