Immigration Law

Recent Posts

CA4 Vacates Castro-Tum
Posted on 29 Aug 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Zuniga Romero v. Barr "After an immigration judge (“IJ”) denied Jesus Zuniga Romero’s request for administrative closure of his case—which would have removed it from the IJ’s active docket pending the completion of... Read More

Tags: castro-tum , barr , bia

EOIR Interim Rule (Aug. 26, 2019)
Posted on 25 Aug 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 165 / Monday, August 26, 2019 "This interim rule amends the regulations related to the internal organization of the Executive Office for Immigration Review (‘‘EOIR’’). This interim rule reflects... Read More

Major Changes at EOIR Spark Strong Reactions
Posted on 23 Aug 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

EOIR will publish an Interim Rule on Monday, Aug. 26, 2019. An advance copy is posted here . The National Association of Immigration Judges posted its reaction here . Former BIA Chairman and Immigration Judge Paul W. Schmidt posted his reaction here... Read More

Tags: barr , bia , eoir

A.G. Barr Adds Six New BIA Members
Posted on 23 Aug 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

EOIR, Aug. 23, 2019 "The Executive Office for Immigration Review today announced the investiture of six new Board members. Board of Immigration Appeals Chairman David L. Neal presided over the investiture during a ceremony held Aug. 23, 2019, at... Read More

Tags: barr , bia , eoir

Pro Se Evidence Remand at CA4: Ali v. Atty. Gen.
Posted on 6 Aug 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Ali v. Atty. Gen. "All in all, the Board’s opinion in this case is a classic example of a decision that is incapable of review due to a lack of reasoned consideration. Its failure to discuss “highly relevant” evidence, see Min... Read More

Tags: bia , Evidence

EOIR's Troubling New Regulations - Jeffrey S. Chase
Posted on 9 Jul 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Jeffrey S. Chase, July 5, 2019 "On July 2, the Department of Justice published final regulations impacting how decisions of immigration judges will be reviewed, both on appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals and by certification to the Attorney... Read More

IJ Asylum Grant: Guatemala, Gender
Posted on 9 Jul 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Former IJ Jeffrey S. Chase writes: "[ Here ] is a recent (May 20) grant of asylum by IJ Steve Morley in Philadelphia, who, you may remember, was the IJ who was targeted and had cases taken off his docket for refusing to order a minor respondent removed... Read More

EOIR Final Rule - Board of Immigration Appeals: Affirmance Without Opinion, Referral for Panel Review, and Publication of Decisions as Precedents
Posted on 1 Jul 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Federal Register / Vol. 84, No. 127 / Tuesday, July 2, 2019 "The Department of Justice (Department) is publishing this final rule (“final rule” or “rule”) to amend the regulations regarding the administrative review procedures... Read More

Tags: bia , eoir , final rule

BIBcast with Kathrin S. Mautino!
Posted on 21 Jun 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

San Diego superstar Kathrin S. Mautino discovers hidden gems among "old" BIA cases that can help you solve today's knotty litigation problems. Listen to the audio here . Read More

Jeffrey S. Chase: The BIA and Selective Dismissal
Posted on 7 Jun 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Jeffrey S. Chase, June 7, 2019 "On May 31, the BIA published a precedent decision in Matters of Andrade Jaso and Carbajal Ayala . In that decision, Board Member Garry Malphrus (writing for a panel that included Hugh Mullane and Ellen Liebowitz... Read More

Unpub. BIA Victory: Mexico, WH/CAT, Imputed Nationality
Posted on 4 Jun 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Amanda Gray writes: "I wanted to share this great withholding decision I received today. The BIA reversed [an IJ in] Salt Lake City in a detained withholding / CAT case (client is in Tacoma, WA in withholding only proceedings) on the grounds that... Read More

Barr Certifies 'Judicial Alteration' Cases to Himself
Posted on 29 May 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Matter of Thomas & Thompson, 27 I&N Dec. 556 (A.G. 2019) Pursuant to 8 C.F.R. § 1003.1(h)(1)(i), I direct the Board of Immigration Appeals (“Board”) to refer these cases to me for review of its decisions. The Board’s decisions... Read More

Court Slaps USCIS in MAVNI Natz Lawsuit: Nio v. DHS
Posted on 23 May 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Nio v. DHS, May 22, 2019 "The question before the Court is whether the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (“DHS”) and its sub-agency U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (“USCIS”) acted lawfully when they instituted... Read More

Tags: nio , mavni , bia , APA , Naturalization , USCIS

2 New BIA Decisions on Pereira
Posted on 22 May 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

27 I&N Dec. 546 (BIA 2019), Matter of PENA-MEJIA - Neither rescission of an in absentia order of removal nor termination of the proceedings is required where an alien did not appear at a scheduled hearing after being served with a notice to appear... Read More

BIA, En Banc (9-6) on Pereira, Bermudez-Cota: Matter of Mendoza-Hernandez and Capula-Cortes
Posted on 1 May 2019 by Daniel M. Kowalski

Matter of Mendoza-Hernandez and Capula-Cortes, 27 I&N Dec. 520 (BIA 2019) Board En Banc: NEAL, Chairman; MALPHRUS, WENDTLAND, MULLANE, GREER, MANN, O’CONNOR, LIEBOWITZ, and KELLY, Board Members. Dissenting Opinion: GUENDELSBERGER, joined by... Read More

  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA MTR Victory: Russia, Homosexuality

    Aaron C. Hall writes: "Our client first applied for asylum in 1992 based on persecution by the KGB in the former Soviet Union on account of his political opinion. His application was denied by the IJ and on appeal by the BIA and the Tenth Circuit. He then filed a Motion to Reopen with the BIA...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Remand Victory: Using Martinez v. Mukasey

    "[I]n Martinez v. Mukasey, 519 F.3d 532 (5th Cir. 2008), the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reached a different result than that reached by this Board in Matter of Koljenovic, 25 I&N Dec. 219 (BIA 2010) (LJ. at 6-7). The Fifth Circuit determined that the statutory bar on...
  • Blog Post: Unpublished BIA Victory: 212(c), Ineffective Assistance, Mental Capacity

    Jon Eric Garde of Las Vegas recently received good news from the BIA, granting his motion to reopen a case that had last been before the Board in 1998! Matter of Stevens, A035-172-124 - Detroit, Oct. 12, 2011, unpublished .
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Victory: Mali, FGM, one-year bar

    Prof. Geoffrey A. Hoffman writes: " The UH Immigration Clinic has just won an appeal from the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) involving an asylum claim which was denied previously by the Immigration Court here in Houston. The claim was filed by a mother of a family of four. She had suffered...

    "This case will make an interesting teaching example for immigration professors discussing the ramifications of the Attorney General’s precedential decision on female genital mutilation (FGM), Matter of A-T- I&N Dec. 617 (A.G. 2008). In the decision rendered by the BIA on October 14...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Remand Victory: AOS, False Claim

    Matthew L. Kolken writes: " Attached is a BIA decision overturning the IJ in Buffalo. He ruled that my client was statutorily ineligible for adjustment due to an alleged false claim to US citizenship that never happened. I moved for recusal during the course of proceedings, which was denied...
  • Blog Post: Seventh Circuit on JRADs, due process, ineffective assistance

    "Jorge Solis-Chavez is a native of Guatemala who has been a lawful permanent resident in the United States since 1980. In 2007 he faced removal as a result of a 1989 Illinois conviction for sexual abuse of a minor. He initially argued that he was not subject to removal because the judge who convicted...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Remand Victory: CAT, Mexico, credibility, social group

    "[T]he adverse credibility finding is clearly erroneous inasmuch as it based on minor inconsistencies and improper speculation (Resp. Br. at 15). See Ren v. Holder, 648 F.3d 1 (9th Cir. 2011) (trivial inconsistencies that under total circumstances have no bearing on petitioner's veracity should...
  • Blog Post: Fourth Circuit on evidence: Tassi v. Holder

    "[O]ur analysis of Tassi’s petition for review exposes several categories of error. For example, the IJ contravened the principle that corroborative evidence supporting an asylum application cannot be rejected solely because it does not strictly comport with the rules of evidence or because...
  • Blog Post: New BIA Member Appointed

    "The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) today announced that Attorney General Eric Holder appointed Ana Landazabal Mann to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). Ms. Mann will begin work as a board member on November 21, 2011." - EOIR, Nov. 15, 2011 .
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Victory: child abuse

    Attorney Aaron Tarin writes: " Here is a bit of good news to those battling the toxic spread of Matter of Soram 's expansive definition of child abuse. [In an unpublished decision dated Dec. 6, 2011 ] the Board held that Assault with Substantial Bodily Injury in the Presence of a Child...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA mental competency remand victory

    "[A] remand is appropriate to enable the parties to apply the framework set out in Matter of M-A-M-, supra, including consideration of whether the respondent has a mental illness that impacted her credibility at the hearing." - Matter of X-, Oct. 5, 2011 . [Hats off to Rachel Gore Freed at...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA asylum remand victory: arrest warrant as pretext

    "On appeal, the respondent argues that the arrest warrant issued against him is a pretext for political persecution. See Long v. Holder 620 F3d 162, 166 (2nd Cir. 2010) (noting that prosecution that is pretext for political persecution is not on account of law enforcement); Matter of Sibrun, 18...
  • Blog Post: What the BIA is reading

    Here's a link to the Nov-Dec 2011 issue (Vol. 5, No. 10) of the Immigration Law Advisor , published by EOIR.
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Cancellation Victory

    Jose Quintero of Catholic Charities, Miami, won this recent victory at the BIA. Bravo! "[W]e conclude that the respondent warrants cancellation of removal as a matter of discretion. In finding that the respondent did not merit a favorable exercise of discretion, the Immigration Judge properly considered...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Visa Petition Victory: MTF Transgender Married to USC Male

    "Having considered the unique circumstances of this case, we find that, while it does not mirror the factual scenario of Matter of Lovo , supra, it is a variation of our finding in that case. ... [W]e find that the petitioner and the beneficiary have a "monogamous, heterosexual marriage."...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Waiver Victory: 'Otherwise Admissible'

    Russell R. Abrutyn writes: "Although there were a number of issues in this case, the primary issue was whether the noncitizen, who married a few days before immigrating as the child of a DV winner, was eligible for a 237(a)(1)(H) waiver. The Immigration Judge and, initially, the BIA held ...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Res Judicata Victory: Gaytan-Castro

    "We agree with the Immigration Judge that the present removal proceedings are barred under the doctrine of res judicata even if the respondent was erroneously granted adjustment of status in the prior proceedings. ... Although the instant proceedings are based on a different charge of removability...
  • Blog Post: BIA on divisibility: Matter of Lanferman, ID 3744, 25 I&N Dec. 721 (BIA 2012)

    Matter of Lanferman, ID 3744, 25 I&N Dec. 721 (BIA 2012) - A criminal statute is divisible, regardless of its structure, if, based on the elements of the offense, some but not all violations of the statute give rise to grounds for removal or ineligibility for relief.
  • Blog Post: David Neal new BIA Chairman; Robin Stutman new CAHO

    "The Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) announced today that the Attorney General has appointed a new Chairman of the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). Effective March 26, 2012, David L. Neal, previously Vice Chairman of the BIA, will serve the agency as Chairman. Mr. Neal...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA 'Extreme Cruelty' Victory: Matter of A-L-M-

    "The principal question on remand is whether the respondent remains eligible for special rule cancellation of removal despite the death of her daughter. We find that she does." - Matter of A-L-M-, Mar. 5, 2012, unpub . Hats off to Katherine Barrett Wiik, National Network to End Violence...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Asylum Victory; Egypt, Persecution, 'Unreasonable Expectations'

    David L. Cleveland writes: "An asylum applicant from Egypt suffered real harm, including an assault by an unidentified man that left her unconscious, but was denied by the IJ for failing to show the motive of her attacker. The BIA said that the IJ "may have imposed an unreasonable expectation...
  • Blog Post: Matter of A-Y-M-, ID 3750, 25 I&N Dec. 791 (BIA 2012)

    Matter of A-Y-M-, ID 3750, 25 I&N Dec. 791 (BIA 2012) - Following the enactment of the Child Status Protection Act, Pub. L. No. 107-208, 116 Stat. 927 (2002), an unmarried alien seeking derivative asylum status based on the approval of his or her parent’s application for asylum who turned 21...
  • Blog Post: Searching for that Unpub. BIA Case?

    A reader writes: "I would be very grateful if you could locate and transmit to me copies of two unreported Board cases cited at page 359 of the March 15, 2007 BIB: Matter of Mitter , A73-767-969 (BIA July 20, 2006) and Matter of Lee , A79-626-439 (BIA Apr. 12, 2006)." I used the "Search"...
  • Blog Post: Unpub. BIA Marriage Fraud Victory: Matter of Kagau

    "While the Notice Of Intent to Deny ("NOID") the previous visa petition questioned the validity of the underlying marriage and referenced the fraud provision under section 204(c) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, 8 U.S.c. § 1154(c), neither the NOID nor the subsequent Field...