By Eric Geringswald | CSC Highlights from the 2023 Nevada Legislative Session Nevada's General Assembly concluded the 82 nd legislative session in June, enacting more than three dozen statutory...
By Eric Geringswald | CSC Georgia Business Law Georgia legislators approved a number of changes to the state's business entity statutes during the 2023 session, including changes to the securities...
By Eric Geringswald | CSC Virginia Business Law 2023 Virginia business attorneys and professionals take note - the latest edition of Virginia Laws Governing Business Entities Annotated from CSC Publishing...
By Bruce Bergman | Partner, Berkman, Henoch, Peterson, Peddy & Fenchel, P.C. The Voluntary Payment Doctrine and Mortgage Foreclosures In the real world of mortgage foreclosure , there are events...
Law Librarians and Equity In the world of legal education , law librarians stand as the champions of curation, organization, and dissemination of legal information for first-year law students, seniors...
Healthcare Access for Transgender Patients
Various bills in state legislatures across the United States are seeking to ban or limit gender-affirming healthcare options for transgender children and teenagers, with new laws carrying the threat of imprisonment for medical providers and parents who do not comply.
This trend culminated this month with Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey signing a bill that criminalizes gender-affirming healthcare for transgender and nonbinary youth. The law makes it a felony, punishable by up to 10 years in prison and a fine of up to $15,000, for doctors to provide or recommend interventions such as puberty blockers and hormone therapies to people younger than 19-years-old.
Alabama isn’t alone in this – Texas’ governor and attorney general have labelled gender-affirming healthcare for minors as “child abuse” and last month a bill passed the Idaho House that would make medical treatments for transgender youth a felony, punishable by life in prison.
Valarie Blake, professor of law at West Virginia University and author of LexisNexis Civil Rights & Strategy Series: Federal Health Care Laws, says this trend is likely to continue and will likely lead to a clash of state and federal laws at the expense of medical professionals.
“The position healthcare providers are in is untenable,” Blake says. “They may face criminal, civil, and licensure threats all for doing what they believe is medically appropriate, and what federal antidiscrimination law demands of them.”
Gender Discrimination and the Affordable Care Act
Section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act bans sex discrimination by healthcare providers that take federal money, and recent case law suggests this includes gender identity discrimination, but there’s still a lot that is yet to be decided
“Enforcement here is tricky,” says Blake. “The healthcare workers who have to comply with these laws are not the ones in the wrong. They are being put in an impossible place between federal and state laws.”
There could be an increase in federal cases seeking to halt enforcement of these laws and potentially federal enforcement from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Service’s Office for Civil Rights (HHS OCR).
HHS OCR has a rule interpreting Section 1557 that can be found at 45 CFR 92 et seq. The rule has gone through several iterations, first by the Obama administration, then the Trump administration. The Biden administration is anticipated to propose their version in the coming months.
But what are the implications? Very likely more cases and continued litigation.
“Federal lawmakers don’t want to penalize the wrong group and state lawmakers know this,” Blake says. “So they’re continuing with these unlawful bills. Ultimately, litigation may be needed to enjoin the enforcement of these state laws.”
Health law resources are on sale for the month of May at the LexisNexis Store, click here to browse legal titles from a variety of practice areas.
For the latest from LexisNexis Law Books, follow us on LinkedIn, Twitter, and Facebook. Visit the LexisNexis Book Store for the latest releases and deals on legal content and law books.